NYC Restaurants

187 Columbia Street
Brooklyn, NY, 11231
(718) 643-5400

Cuisine: Mexican

Menu:   View the Menu

Reader Ratings:

Cititour Review:
I've had several dinners and one brunch at Alma, on the western edge of
Carroll Gardens, and it's official: I don't know of a better or lovelier restaurant currently serving in this city. (And I eat at
restaurants--more often than I'd normally care to admit.)

The ground floor here is occupied by the B61 Bar (so named for the bus
line that passes right nearby). I've heard only good things about it,
but I haven't yet had drinks there. Nor have I eaten on the first level
of the dining room, though I've heard that's really pleasant as well.
I've passed these by so far because I'm hooked on the roof deck, a truly
great space looking over the East River and out onto the Manhattan
skyline. I've eaten there in winter, when a clear plastic tent and heating
lamps keep things warm; and in warm weather that allows for al fresco
meals. Both are wonderful experiences. My recommendation: Go now, while
we've still got some warmer weather left, and again when it's freezing
out and the sense of eating comfortably outside feels like a blessing.

Gary Jacobson's New Mexican menu is varied, with fantastic
combinations, but never pretentious. At dinner, the salsa that arrives first is a
must: well-seasoned, always featuring prime tomatoes (how do they do it
in winter?), and a great introduction to the meal (as is the
not-too-sweet sangria as well). I love the pan-roasted tuna steak topped with
amarillo-chile citrus sauce; and especially the tangy grilled, marinated
shrimp with cucumber-mango salsa. The satisfying Enchiladas Chile
Colorado can be served with chicken and cheese or as a vegetarian dish with
cheese only; my table particularly liked the topping of pumpkin-seed
sauce. Pablano Relleno (poblano chile with chicken and goat cheese) was
also well-received. For dessert, we were instantly addicted to the
ancho-chile flourless chocolate cake, from nearby Margaret Palca Bakery.

For brunch on weekends, follow similar instructions regarding the salsa
(and the sangria, if you so desire). We enjoyed the guacamole and loved
the fried plantains in rich mole poblano sauce, the Mexican potato
salad with jalapenos, and, surprisingly, the side dish of seasoned rice:
much more distinctive on its own than we'd had reason to expect, and a
delicious base for the various sauces and toppings. Huevos Oaxaca, with
black beans, spicy tomato salsa, grilled jalapeno potatoes, and
plantain, was filling but never oppressive. The coffee was strong without being
overly bracing.

Great basic ingredients, creative but unfussy recipes, warm service,
and that amazing roof space combine for an experience that celebrates the
foundations of a great meal. Jacobson and company seem to know that
when you've got the right stuff, you don't need bells and whistles to jazz
it up; letting quality shine through is the way to go.
Review By: Pamela Grossman

Neighborhood: Carroll Gardens

Entree Price: $15-20

What do you think?

Latest Cititour News

A Fireside Roasting and Toasting Christmas at Sweetbriar
December 7, 2022, 9:26 pm ET
Get the details.

A New Filipino Tasting Menu at 8282
December 7, 2022, 9:16 pm ET
Get the details.

Burger Expert George Motz to Host 2 Pop-Ups Ahead of Restaurant Opening
December 6, 2022, 7:50 pm ET
Get the details.

Leave a Comment