Menu: Buttercup Bake Shop

Phone: (212) 350-4144

Return to restaurant page

Cupcakes

*Buttercup Golden (Yellow), *Chocolate, “Devil Dog,” German Chocolate, Lady Baltimore, Lemon, Red Velvet, Sour Cream Spice$1.75 each*with either chocolate or vanilla buttercream

Layer Cakes

Apple Walnut CakeA moist and fruity cake, made with whole wheat flour, fresh apples and walnuts, Iced with caramel cream cheese frosting 2 Layer 9" $35

Buttercup Golden Cake*Our "not-so-standard" yellow (or vanilla) cake; Our most popular recommendation for birthdays 3 Layer 9" $402 Layer 9" $322 Layer 7" $22

Carrot CakeMade with fresh carrots and apples, laced with pecans, Iced with cream cheese frosting (Note: Iced only between layers and on top of cake)3 Layer 9" $40

Chocolate Cake*A rich, chocolaty cake made moist with buttermilk and sour cream 3 Layer 9" $402 Layer 9" $322 Layer 7" $22

Coconut CakeA yellow cake with coconut filling between the layers, Frosted with gooey meringue ("boiled icing"), Topped with shredded coconut 3 Layer 9" $403 Layer 7" $24

German Chocolate CakeA light sweet chocolate cake, filled with coconut pecan filling (Note: Iced only between layers and on top of cake)3 Layer 9" $403 Layer 7" $24

Hummingbird CakeA moist, fruity cake filled with bananas, pineapple and pecans (tastes like your favorite banana bread!), Iced with cream cheese frosting 2 Layer 9" $35

Lady Baltimore CakeAn almond-flavored white cake filled with coconut, candied cherries, cookie crumbs and almonds, Frosted with gooey meringue ("boiled icing"), Topped with coconut, cookie crumble and cherry halves 3 Layer 9" $403 Layer 7" $24

Lemon Cake*A very lemony cake made with fresh lemon juice and zest, Tastes best topped with lemon buttercream3 Layer 9" $403 Layer 7" $24

 Red Velvet CakeYellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake), Iced with cream cheese frosting (Note: Iced only between layers and on top of cake) 3 Layer 9" $403 Layer 7" $24

Sour Cream Spice CakeA dense cake packed with all your favorite spices, filled with walnuts and raisins, Iced with cream cheese frosting 2 Layer 9" $352 Layer 7" $22

*These cakes can accommodatethe following icings:Vanilla ButtercreamChocolate ButtercreamMocha ButtercreamLemon ButtercreamPeanut Butter Icing

Decoration available: for layer cakes:$2 inscription only$4 border decoration only$6 inscription plus border decoration$10 select designs

More Legendary Cakes 10 inch: $24

Angel Food Cake with Strawberry GlazeApple Pecan CakeBlueberry Coffee CakeChocolate Sour Cream CakeLemon Vanilla Bundt CakeOrange Marble Bundt Cake  

Cheesecakes 

Individual Mini: $4.00

Caramel PecanChocolate AlmondChocolate SwirlRaspberry MarzipanToffee Crunch  Other Good Stuff    Assorted Pies (Seasonal)Apple, Chocolate Pudding, Ice Box, Lime, Pecan, Lemon Meringue, Pumpkin, Strawberry Rhubarb6 inch: $7 9 inch: $16

Assorted Bars and SquaresBrownies, Fruit Bars, Lemon Bars, Peanut Butter Mud Bars, Rice Krispie Treats, Magic Bars$2.50

Banana Pudding/Chocolate TrifleIn single serving sizes ($3.50 and $5.00) or 64 ounce tub to-go $20

Assorted Breakfast ItemsBlueberry Muffins, Oatmeal Muffins, Raspberry Cream Cheese Buns, Sour Cream Pecan Buns$1.25 to $1.50

 

 

BUTTERCUP BAKE SHOP

Please note: all menu items and prices are subject to change.