City Island Lobster House
Restaurant Menu
Appetizers
ColdJumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5) 13.95Whole Lobster in Shell (cold) 14.95Scungilli Salad 9.95Calamari Salad 9.95Cold Snow Crab Legs Cluster 13.95Freshly Shucked Clams Littlenecks or Cherrystones ½ Doz. 8.95 1 Doz. 14.95Bluepoint Oysters (each) 1.50Fruit Salad 5.95Seafood Salad Combo 14.95Hot Buffalo Wings 8.95Mozzarella Sticks 8.95Fried Calamari 9.95Tender Chicken Fingers 8.95Potato Skins w/cheese 4.95 add Bacon or Broccoli 5.95Oysters Rockefeller 11.95Clams Oreganato (6) 9.95Maryland Crabcakes 13.95Littleneck Steamers in Garlic or Red Sauce 15.95Mussels steamed in Garlic or Red Sauce 12.95A whooping pot if Ipwich Steamers with butter 15.95
Soups
Soup of the Day 4.95Lobster House Bisque 3.95Manhattan Clam Chowder 3.95New England Chowder 3.95French Onion Soup 4.95
For Land Lubbers
New York Shell Steak 19.95Nice & juicy BBQ Chicken 17.95Aged thickly cut Filet Mignon Filet Mignon 12 oz. 22.95Boneless Prime Rib of Beef 20.95Fried Chicken 16.95Baby Back Pork Ribs & Chicken Combination 17.95 Baby Back Pork Ribs (full rack) 19.95Chicken Combination 16.95
Mediterranean DishesServed over a bed of fresh pasta
Pasta Del Mar 34.95Lobster, shrimp, clams, mussels, all served in a marinara or garlic sauce.
Clam Sauce Pasta 17.95Tender clams chopped in a tasty clam sauce over fresh pasta.
Picolla 19.95Clams and mussels served whole in a garlic sauce or in a marinara sauce over fresh pasta.
Calamari or Scungilli 18.95Served in a marinara sauce or in our special garlic sauce.
Shrimp Marinara 25.95Shrimp, clams, mussels all served in a marinara or garlic sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana 18.95Tender breasts of chicken smothered in Parmigiana cheese and red sauce.
Chicken Francese 18.95Tender breasts of chicken sautéed in a butter, white wine and fresh lemon sauce.
Shrimp Parmigiana 24.95Large shrimp smothered in Parmigiana cheese and red sauce.
Shrimp Francese 24.95Large shrimp sautéed in a butter, white wine sauce and fresh lemon sauce.
Sole Francese 22.95Fresh Sole sautéed in a butter and lemon white wine sauce.
Catch of the DayWe only select and serve the finest fish at our City Island Lobster House Restaurant
Tuna, Halibut or Swordfish 23.95Norwegian Salmon 20.95 Mahi - Mahi 22.95Boston Scrod 19.95Filet of Sole 20.95Whole Red Snapper 22.95Bluefish 18.95Red Snapper Filet 20.95
Prepared fresh to order please specify grilled, baked, fried or sautéed. For those who prefer spicy we can prepare it Cajun or Creole.
City Island FavoritesTried and Proven Island Favorites
Twin Broiled Lobster Tails 37.95Jumbo Shrimp Scampi 23.95Baked Scallops & Shrimp Combination 31.95Baked Baby Tail Platter 31.95Baked Day Boat Sea Scallops 23.95Broiled Seafood Combination 29.95Maryland Crab Cakes 23.95
From Our FryersDeep fried and crispy!
Jumbo Fried Shrimp 22.95Fried Sea Scallops 23.95Fried Yellow Tail Filet of Sole 20.95Tender Baby Calamari 19.95Authentic Fish & Chips 18.95Crispy Fried Maryland Soft Shell Crabs 25.95Fisherman's Combo Platter 29.95Served with calamari, shrimp, scallops, filet of sole & soft shell crabs.Freshly Shucked Fried Oysters 22.95Freshly Shucked Whole Fried Clams 20.95
Extraordinary CombinationsCreate your very own Combos!
Whole Lobster 35.95Served broiled with your choice of...Shell Steak - Prime Rib - Spare Ribs - Fried Shrimp or Scallops
Snow Crab Legs 29.95Served broiled with your choice of...Shell Steak - Prime Rib - Spare Ribs - Fried Shrimp or Scallops
Lobster Tail 37.95Served broiled with your choice of...Shell Steak - Prime Rib - Spare Ribs - Fried Shrimp or Scallops
Broiled or Fried Shrimp 31.95Served broiled with your choice of...Shell Steak - Prime Rib - Spare Ribs - Fried Shrimp or Scallops
King Crab Legs 39.95Served broiled with your choice of...Shell Steak - Prime Rib - Spare Ribs - Fried Shrimp or Scallops
Filet Mignon $5.00 extra · Surf & Turf Combo $5.00 extra $5.00 plate charge for sharing
LobstersOur Specialty Fresh from Maine Lobsters served steamed or broiled
Lobster Sizes: 1-¼ lbs. 1-½ lbs. 2 lbs. 17.95 24.95 30.95
Jumbo Lobsters 3 to 6 lb. are availablepriced accordingly
1-¼ lbs. Twin (2) Maine Lobsters 29.951-¼ lbs. Triple (3) Maine Lobsters 40.95Lobster prices subject to market price fluctuations.
Any of our broiled Lobsters can be stuffed with shrimp or crabmeat for just 9.95 each extra.
Lobster House FeastsAll of our Lobster House Feasts are served for two (2).There is a $5.00 plate charge for each additional person sharing.
BBQ Lobster FeastA whole lobster with baby back pork ribs, BBQ chicken, jumbo fried shrimp and large snow crab legs. All served with corn on the cob, rice, french fries and onion rings.
Don Italiano Lobster FeastA whole lobster with shrimp, mussels, clams, whole crabs, and snow crabs. All sautéed with our famous marinara sauce or garlic sauce served over a bed of fresh imported pasta.
Cold Lobster ComboA whole cold lobster with shrimp cocktail, scungilli, calamari, mussels, littleneck clams, snow crab legs all served over a bed of fresh greens.
any of the above 59.95
Lobster House's Ultimate Seafood Feast Plenty of Succulent Lobster, Jumbo Shrimp, Scallops, clams, Mussels, Scungilli & Calamari With Choice of Red or White Sauce Over a Bed of Imported Linguini 69.95
Lobster House Crab CornerThough we specialize in lobster, we have the world's best Crabs!
From AlaskaKing Crab Legs 39.95Snow Crab Leg Clusters 29.95Served broiled or steamed
From Maryland Whole Blue Claw Crabs 25.95Served broiled or steamed or Baltimore Style (spicy with Old bay) also served with Garlic or Red Sauce.
Chilled Shellfish Sampler 29.95Half of a 1-1/4 lb. Lobster, 3 Cherrystone Clams, 3 Oysters and 3 Chilled JUMBO Shrimp.
PLEASE NOTE: All menu items and prices are subject to change.
Sign up for our newsletter !