The Original New York Milkshake Company
Restaurant Menu
Shakes & Malts
24oz. $5.00
16oz. $4.00
We also make Low Fat Frozen Yogurt Shakes!
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Black n' White
Ultra Chocolate
Coffee
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Pina Colada
Blue Raspberry
Grape
Lemonade
Lemon Lime
Watermelon
Cherry Vanilla
Mint Chip
Green Tea
Cookies & Cream
Banana
Butter Pecan
Pistachio
Mocha
Creamsicle
Fruit Punch
Pineapple
Vanilla Bean
Flavor of the Week
Vanilla Bean, Ultra Chocolate, and Cherry Vanilla ~ add .50
Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
American, Provolone, Monterey Jack, Mozzerella
(Combos Available) ~ $4.50
Cheddar, Buffalo Cheddar, Cheddar & Pepperoni, Swiss,
Muenster, Fresh Mozzerella ~ $5.00
~ Add Tomato .50
~ Add Ham, Bacon, Egg $1.00
Peanut Butter & Jelly (Grilled or Regular) ~ $3.50
Tomato Soup ~ Sm. $4.00, Lg. $5.00
Chicken Noodle Soup ~ Sm. $4.00, Lg. $5.00
Ice Cream Specialities
Hot Waffle & Ice Cream ~ $3.50
Cup of Ice Cream ~ $3.50
Hot Ice Cream Floats ~ $3.50
Root Beer Float ~ $4.00
Soda Fountain
Old School Brooklyn Egg Cream ~ 16oz. $2.50, 24oz. $3.50
Cherry, Grape, Pineapple, Orange, Watermelon, Pina Colada,
Blue Raspberry, Lemonade, Fruit Punch ~ $1.50, Lime Ricky ~ $2.00
Hot Chocolate ~ $1.00
Coffee $1.00, Coffee a la Mode (with scoop of Ice Cream) ~ $3.50
Tea ~ Regular, Camomile, Earl Grey, Lipton ~ $1.00
Herbal Tea ~ Lemon & Fevergrass, Honey & Ginger, Peppermint,
Cerassie, Honey & Ginger, and Ginger & Sorrel ~ $1.00
Early Bird Special
Half Sandwich & Soup ~ $6.00
Special St. Mark's Sandwich ~
Changes Weekly ~ $6.00
Ask for your "Buy 9 get 10th Free" Card ~ Grilled Cheese or Shake
PLEASE NOTE: All menu items and prices are subject to change.
Sign up for our newsletter !